On this page
Start by finding out which kind of no you got, because there are three common ones and each has a different fix. The counselor may be applying a written rule your teen doesn't meet, in which case the fix is meeting the rule. It may be a judgment call about readiness, which calls for a conversation with evidence. Or it may be a workload problem on the school's side, where the fix is making the paperwork easy. In most states the school can't refuse an eligible student outright, but it can slow one down, so it helps to know which situation you're in before you respond.
Is it a rule, or an opinion?
Ask, directly and politely, “Is there a written policy that isn’t met here, or is this your recommendation?” Counselors hear that question often, and most answer it plainly.
If it’s a written policy, ask to see it. District dual enrollment rules are usually in the course catalog, the student handbook, or a board policy, and they tend to be specific, such as a GPA floor, a grade-level restriction, a cap on courses per term, or a requirement that the course not be offered at the high school. Once you can read the rule, you can plan around it or, occasionally, show that it doesn’t apply to your teen.
If it’s a recommendation, that’s a different conversation, and a fair one to have, because counselors see students overreach every year and what they are usually missing is information about your particular teen.
What if the concern is readiness?
Bring evidence, and shrink the request. The evidence is your teen’s record in the subject they’d take, meaning grades, a teacher who would vouch for them, and a test score if the program uses one. The smaller request is one course, in that subject, this term. It’s hard to argue that a student with an A in English can’t handle College Composition, and it’s easy to agree to a single course as a trial, so most readiness objections dissolve when the request shrinks from “dual enrollment” to “one course in the thing she’s best at.”
If your teen’s record doesn’t support the request, the counselor may be right, and a semester of strong grades in high school is a better next step than a college course that goes badly and stays on a college transcript.
What if the concern is the school’s side?
Sometimes the hesitation isn’t about your teen at all. Dual enrollment means paperwork, a schedule that doesn’t line up with the bell, a seat the high school has to release, and in some states money that follows the student out of the district, so a counselor with a caseload in the hundreds has reasons to prefer the simpler path.
You can’t fix the caseload, but you can make your teen the easy case by showing up with the form filled out, the college’s requirements already checked, the course already chosen from the approved list, and the deadline written at the top. Then ask what else the counselor needs from you.
Can the school say no?
Often it can’t, if the student is eligible, though this depends on your state. Programs created by state law, like Minnesota’s PSEO, Washington’s Running Start, and Ohio’s College Credit Plus, give eligible students the right to participate, and the district’s role is to process the enrollment rather than to grant permission. A district can enforce the program’s written rules and its own scheduling limits, but it generally can’t substitute its judgment for the state’s eligibility standard.
You still need the counselor to sign forms, send transcripts, and put the course on the schedule, and a cooperative counselor makes all of that go faster, which is why we tell families to lead with the conversation and bring up the statute only if the conversation fails.
What if it still fails?
Go up one level, and do it in writing. Send a short email to the principal or the district’s dual enrollment coordinator that says what your teen asked for, what the response was, and what you are requesting, with the relevant program rule quoted or linked. Keep it factual and copy the counselor. Most of these get resolved at the first reply, because the coordinator knows the rule and would rather fix it than field a call from the state.
If your state’s education agency has a dual enrollment office, it usually has a contact for this situation, and the time to use it is after the district has had a chance to respond.
FAQ
Can a high school refuse to let a student do dual enrollment? It depends on the state. In programs created by state law, an eligible student generally has the right to participate and the school’s role is to process the enrollment, though the school can enforce the program’s written rules and its own scheduling limits.
What should you say to a counselor who is discouraging dual enrollment? Ask whether the objection is a written policy or a recommendation. If it’s a recommendation, bring your teen’s record in the subject and ask for a single course as a trial.
Who do you contact if the counselor won’t sign the dual enrollment form? The principal or the district’s dual enrollment coordinator, in a short factual email that copies the counselor. After that, the state education agency’s dual enrollment office.
Why would a counselor be against dual enrollment? Usually a written rule your teen doesn’t meet, a readiness concern based on past students, or the paperwork and scheduling burden on the school’s side, and each of those has a different fix.
Should you push if the counselor thinks your teen isn’t ready? Only if the record supports it. If your teen’s grades in the subject are strong, ask for one course. If they aren’t, a strong high school semester is the better next move.